« Don't worry about contributed content: Wikipedia has figured it all out! | Main | What is pollution, what is manipulation? »

November 26, 2008

New UCC opportunity, new opportunity for manipulation and spam

Google has made available a striking set of new features for search, which it calls SearchWiki. If you are logged in to a Google account, when you search you will have the ability to add or delete results you get if you search that page again, re-order the results, and post comments (which can be viewed by others).

But the comments are user-contributed content: this is a relatively open publishing platform. If others search on the same keyword(s) and select "view comments" they will see what you entered. Which might be advertising, political speech, whatever. As Lauren Weinstein points out, this is an obvious opportunity for pollution, and (to a lesser extent in my humble opinion, because there is no straightforward way to affect the behavior of other users) manipulation. In fact, she finds that comment wars and nastiness started within hours of SearchWiki's availability:

It seem inevitable that popular search results in particular will
quickly become laden with all manner of "dueling comments" which can
quickly descend into nastiness and even potentially libel. In fact,
a quick survey of some obvious search queries shows that in the few
hours that SearchWiki has been generally available, this pattern is
*already* beginning to become established. It doesn't take a
lot of imagination to visualize the scale of what could happen with
the search results for anybody or anything who is the least bit
controversial.

Lauren even suggests that lawsuits are likely by site owners whose links in Google become polluted, presumably claiming they have some sort of property right in clean display of their beachfront URL.

Posted by jmm at November 26, 2008 10:27 AM

Comments

Login to leave a comment. Create a new account.